Skip to content

Your Basket

Probiotics vs Prebiotics: What's the Difference?

Probiotics vs Prebiotics: What's the Difference?

If you've ever stood in the yoghurt aisle wondering whether "live cultures" actually matter, or spotted "prebiotic fibre" on a cereal box and assumed it meant the same thing, you're in good company.

Probiotics are live microorganisms, mostly bacteria and some yeasts, that can benefit your health when you take the right quantities. Prebiotics are types of fibre your body can't digest, which travel to your large bowel and feed the helpful bacteria already living there. Put simply, probiotics add good bacteria to your gut, and prebiotics give those bacteria something to eat.

Here's an easy way to picture it. If you've ever kept a sourdough starter, the bubbling starter is the live culture, and the flour you feed it every day is what keeps it alive. Your gut works in a similar way. Probiotics add microbes and prebiotics provide food for the beneficial bacteria already there, although probiotic bacteria don't necessarily settle in or stay in your gut permanently, even when you have prebiotics alongside them.

What is a prebiotic?

A prebiotic is a type of fibre or plant compound that your body can't break down on its own. Instead of being absorbed in your small intestine, it reaches your large bowel intact, where certain friendly bacteria use it as fuel. The International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics (ISAPP) defines a prebiotic as something that's selectively used by the microorganisms in your body and gives you a health benefit.

That word "selectively" matters. Not all fibre is a prebiotic. Prebiotics feed particular groups of beneficial bacteria, such as Bifidobacteria, rather than every microbe in your gut.

When your gut bacteria feed on prebiotics, they produce substances called short-chain fatty acids. You don't need to remember the name. What's useful to know is that these compounds are an energy source for the cells lining your bowel, and scientists are studying their wider role in health. A 2024 review, The Role of Prebiotics in Modulating Gut Microbiota: Implications for Human Health, describes this process as one of the main ways prebiotics shape the balance of bacteria in your gut.

Common prebiotics you'll find in everyday food include:

  • Inulin, found in chicory root, onions, leeks, garlic and Jerusalem artichokes
  • Fructooligosaccharides (often shortened to FOS), found in onions, garlic, asparagus and bananas
  • Galactooligosaccharides, found in beans, lentils and chickpeas
  • Resistant starch, found in slightly green bananas, oats, and potatoes that have been cooked and cooled

So if you're having a potato salad made with cooled new potatoes and red onion, with a side of chickpeas, you're already eating several different prebiotics without trying.

What are probiotics?

Probiotics are live microorganisms that give you a health benefit when you take them in adequate amounts. That's the internationally agreed ISAPP definition, and it's stricter than most people realise. To count as a probiotic, bacteria need to be alive, present in a meaningful amount and backed by evidence.

The most researched probiotics belong to two groups, Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium. Some yeasts, such as Saccharomyces boulardii, are used too. Each group contains many different strains, and research on one strain doesn't automatically apply to another.

You'll find live cultures in foods such as:

  • Live or "bio" yoghurt
  • Kefir, a fermented milk drink
  • Unpasteurised sauerkraut and kimchi, usually sold in the chilled aisle
  • Probiotic supplements

Strictly speaking, a food that contains live cultures isn't automatically a probiotic. To meet the scientific definition, the specific microorganisms need to have evidence of a health benefit, so think of these foods as sources of live cultures rather than guaranteed probiotics.

There's another catch, too. Not every fermented food still contains live bacteria by the time you eat it. A jar of sauerkraut sitting on a room-temperature shelf has usually been pasteurised, which kills the bacteria. Sourdough bread starts life with live cultures, but baking destroys them. Your best clue is the label, so look for "live cultures" or "contains live bacteria".

The key differences between probiotics and prebiotics

If you only remember one thing, make it this: probiotics are the bacteria, and prebiotics are their food. Here's how they compare side by side.

Probiotics Prebiotics
What they are Live bacteria and yeasts Fibres and plant compounds your body can't digest
Are they alive? Yes No
What they do Add beneficial microbes to your gut Feed the beneficial microbes already there
Where they work Mainly your intestines Mainly your large bowel
Food sources Live yoghurt, kefir, unpasteurised sauerkraut and kimchi contain live cultures, though not all count as probiotics Onions, garlic, leeks, oats, bananas, beans, lentils and chicory root
Effect of cooking Most are killed by heat Many survive cooking
Does the type matter? Yes, effects depend on the specific strain Yes, different fibres feed different bacteria

How to get both from your everyday food

For most people, food is the simplest place to start. The NHS advises adults to eat 30g of fibre a day, yet the average adult in the UK eats around 20g. Closing that gap with more plant foods naturally boosts how many prebiotics you're getting.

Here's what a day with plenty of both might look like:

  • Breakfast: porridge oats topped with a sliced banana and a spoonful of live yoghurt
  • Lunch: lentil soup made with plenty of onion, garlic and leeks
  • Snack: a small glass of kefir
  • Dinner: a stir-fry with asparagus and spring onions, with a forkful of kimchi on the side

If you're not used to much fibre, build up gradually over a few weeks. Going from white toast for breakfast to three bean-heavy meals in a single day is a reliable way to end up gassy and bloated.

Do you need both? Synbiotics explained

Probiotics and prebiotics aren't rivals. They complement each other, because prebiotics feed beneficial bacteria, although having them together doesn't mean probiotic bacteria will settle in your gut for good. When the two are combined in one product or meal, the result is called a synbiotic.

You've probably eaten a synbiotic without realising. A bowl of live yoghurt with sliced banana and oats contains both the bacteria and the fibre to feed them.

Research on synbiotics in healthy adults is still developing. A 2024 analysis, The effect of oral synbiotics on the gut microbiota and inflammatory biomarkers in healthy adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis, pooled randomised controlled trials and found that synbiotics increased levels of Lactobacillus bacteria and propionate, one of the short-chain fatty acids. They didn't change several markers of inflammation, and the authors pointed out big differences in the products, doses and trial lengths. That's the honest picture. Synbiotics do shift the bacteria in your gut, and scientists are still working out exactly what that means for everyday health.

It's also why Swallow's Probiotic Live Cultures include chicory root fibre in every capsule, alongside the live bacteria. Chicory root is a natural source of inulin, so the bacteria arrive with their own food supply.

Plenty of people pair a probiotic with other supplements too, from combining collagen and probiotics to taking magnesium with a probiotic.

What are postbiotics?

You may also have come across the word postbiotics. Postbiotics are what's left once bacteria have done their work, including inactive bacteria and the compounds they produce, such as short-chain fatty acids. ISAPP agreed a formal definition, describing postbiotics as a preparation of inactive microorganisms or their components that gives a health benefit.

If probiotics are the bacteria and prebiotics are their food, postbiotics are what they make. You don't need to hunt them down separately. When you eat prebiotic fibre and probiotic foods, your gut bacteria produce postbiotics naturally.

Food first, or a supplement?

For most healthy adults, a varied diet with plenty of plant foods and some fermented foods is the best foundation. In its guide to Prebiotics & Probiotics, Guts UK, the national charity for the digestive system, recommends eating a wide variety of plant foods rather than taking a probiotic if you have a healthy gut and no digestive symptoms.

Real life doesn't always cooperate, though. A supplement may be worth considering if:

  • You don't eat fermented foods, for example because you avoid dairy and can't stand the taste of kimchi
  • Your routine makes a varied diet hard, such as shift work or frequent travel
  • You've recently finished a course of antibiotics, which can change your gut bacteria. Ask your pharmacist about how to time a probiotic alongside them

If you do choose a probiotic supplement, these are the details worth checking on the label:

  • A live count guaranteed to the end of shelf life, not just at the point of manufacture
  • A capsule designed to protect the bacteria from stomach acid
  • Named strains, so you can see exactly what you're taking
  • A clean formula without unnecessary fillers, colours or additives

Swallow's Probiotic Live Cultures tick each of those boxes. Every capsule contains 35 billion live cultures across multiple Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium strains, plus Saccharomyces boulardii yeast. That 35 billion figure is guaranteed to the end of shelf life, and the delayed-release capsule is designed to pass through your stomach and open in your intestine. The formula is vegan, dairy-free and made in the UK.

It's rated 4.8 out of 5 by customers, with 95% saying they'd recommend it, and it carries a Nourish Awards 2025 badge. The capsule is gastro-resistant, which helps protect the bacteria from stomach acid and may improve how many survive the journey to your gut, although no capsule can guarantee that every strain arrives alive. With Swallow's 6-month money-back promise, you've got plenty of time to decide whether it's right for you.

You can see it alongside other formulas in the digestive health range. If you're wondering how to fit a probiotic around other supplements, our guide to taking a multivitamin and probiotic together covers the practical side.

Are probiotics and prebiotics safe?

Most healthy adults can add prebiotic and probiotic foods to their diet safely. The most common side effect is temporary wind or bloating during the first few days or weeks while your gut adjusts, so starting small helps.

Speak to your GP, pharmacist or a dietitian first if:

  • You have a weakened immune system, are seriously ill or are recovering from surgery
  • You're pregnant or breastfeeding
  • You take regular medication
  • You have irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). Many prebiotic foods, including onions, garlic and beans, are high in FODMAPs, a group of carbohydrates some people with IBS find hard to digest, so a dietitian can help you work out what you tolerate

Sources

Back to blog
Anna Redmayne Porter (ANutr)
Written by

Anna Redmayne Porter (ANutr)

Registered Associate Nutritionist & Health writer

The society of food hygiene & TechnologyNutritionist Registration ANutrNutrition Bsc (Hons)Medicine & Health

Anna Redmayne Porter is a Registered Associate Nutritionist with a unique blend of experience across nutrition, food supplements and cosmetics. With seven years in product technology and development, she has helped bring products from concept to market, working with everyone from ambitious start-ups to established retailers.

Her experience spans product innovation, formulation, taste, delivery formats and the practicalities of turning an idea into a successful product. Combining hands-on industry knowledge with an understanding of nutritional science, she brings a fresh perspective to the world of nutrition and supplementation.

Advanced Probiotic Live Cultures

Free Delivery on All Orders
No Contract
Cancel Anytime
Accepted payment methods
A bottle of Swallow brand probiotic live cultures supplements with a label stating '100% Plant-Based' and 'Dairy-Free Vegan Probiotics'. The bottle contains 30 capsules for dietary use.

Advanced Probiotic Live Cultures

Find Out More

Frequently asked questions

Neither is better, because they do different jobs. Prebiotics feed the beneficial bacteria you already have, while probiotics add new ones. For most people, a fibre-rich diet with some fermented foods covers both. If you're choosing a supplement, one that combines the two gives the live bacteria a food source from the start.

No. Probiotics are living microorganisms. Prebiotics are non-living fibres that feed those microorganisms. They work together, but one is the bacteria and the other is their food.

Yes, and that combination is called a synbiotic. Eating live yoghurt with oats and banana, or taking a probiotic supplement that includes chicory root fibre, are both simple ways to do it.

Not necessarily. If it's a live yoghurt and you're eating plenty of fibre, you're already getting both. Check the label, though, because some yoghurts are heat-treated after fermentation, which kills the bacteria. A supplement can make sense if you want a consistent, measured amount of specific strains every day.